• home
  • posts
  • help lowimpact become wiki survey
  • Posted January 31st, 2021
    8

    Help Lowimpact.org become a wiki, to provide more (and more relevant) information for visitors

    Help Lowimpact.org become a wiki, to provide more (and more relevant) information for visitors

    We’ve been liaising with Simon Grant, of the P2P Foundation Wiki, and making plans for turning Lowimpact.org into a wiki. We already have a network of specialists who provide information for our topics and respond to visitors’ queries. We want to expand this network, as well as the number of topics we cover. We also want to provide information about how to help people re-skill to change careers, as millions of people around the world lose their jobs.

    Simon introduced us to Pascal Carpentier, a Ph.D. Candidate at Erasmus University Rotterdam School of Management, who we’re working with to improve Lowimpact, to make it more useful and interesting for visitors. He wants to understand the motivations, expectations and experiences of visitors to the site, including our network of specialists, and gain insight into what motivates people to share knowledge online. We want to explore ways of providing information, and to add more topics, to take Lowimpact.org to the next level.

    To that end, we’d like to invite you to take a quick survey, devised by Pascal. It will take around 3 minutes. We’re offering a chance to win a free online course of your choice to survey participants. A prize draw will be held at the end of the survey.

    Take the survey.

    Or copy and paste this URL into your browser: https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9sPWbZCjg69AOcl

    Here’s some more information about the research from Pascal (any questions you have for Pascal, you can drop in the comments section below).


    The 90-9-1 rule

    This research starts with an odd discovery. In online communities, such as Wikipedia or Lowimpact, a rule of thumb called the 90-9-1 rule shows that 1% of members create 90% of the content. In comparison, 9% of members mainly focus on editing or commenting. The rest, 90% of members, are merely reading articles, never contributing.

    This rule of thumb has been confirmed scientifically. However, historically all these online community members were studied as if they represented a homogeneous population. I’m interested in understanding what motivates people to participate in online communities such as Lowimpact. I want to look into people’s differing motivations depending on their level of contribution. The result of this survey will also help the Lowimpact team improve the website and provide you with a better website experience and relevant information.

    A bit of background on motivations theory

    Motivation is a psychological force that determines the individual level of effort and persistence when facing an obstacle (Kanfer, 1990).

    The literature on motivation theory describes two primary forms of motivation, the intrinsic and the extrinsic.

    Intrinsic motivation is typically the joy of completing a task and the pleasure of helping others. In contrast, extrinsically motivated people are motivated by the outcome of their behavior, the result of their actions. It is a goal-oriented motivation, where one’s behavior is motivated by the anticipation of a future direct or indirect monetary compensation or an increased reputation (Deci et al., 1975).

    However, according to the self-determination theory (SDT) (Deci & Ryan, 2002) there is no black and white distinction between both forms of motivation. In fact, extrinsic motivations can be internalized by an individual to become almost an intrinsic motivation under certain circumstances.

    Scholars have shown that adhering to the common goal of a community could lead to considering activities related to this community as personally endorsed values.

    Why the Lowimpact website?

    Eco-friendly behavior often requires additional effort, such as sorting rubbish for recycling . A stronger inner motivation could be required to sustain these actions over the long run. Interestingly, we witness that individuals adhering to eco-friendly behaviors internalize these external constraints and transform them into a powerful motivation source. For instance, in ecology, identification with the policy goal is a strong driver for sustainable behavior (Dedeurwaerdere et al., 2016).

    Therefore, the Lowimpact website seems like a place where extrinsic motivation internalization is observable as well. The website’s values and objectives to share knowledge and resources to reduce negative impacts on our planet, as well as system change, are likely to trigger internalized motivations.

    One of the hypotheses I would like to test is the following. Although some experts provide content to the site to raise their profile and reach more potential customers, I suspect their motivation is not purely financial (e.g. extrinsic) but echoes with values and objectives of the Lowimpact community (e.g makes it an internalized motivation).

    Likewise, members coming to the website, posting comments, taking online courses etc. are not solely interested in making savings while producing useful things. They also commit to make the world a better place, and that echoes with their values.

    Thanks for participating in the survey. I hope we can better understand community members’ motivations. We expect rich and nuanced results according to the various levels of contribution to the community, but also to understand how the Lowimpact’s goals influence your motivation and behavior.

    What you need to know about this survey

    Voluntary participation: Your participation is voluntary, and you can stop at any time by closing the online survey. It is not mandatory to answer all questions. There are no legal or economic risks associated with your participation in this study.

    Data collection: The questionnaire comprises 35 questions; it will take you approximately 3 minutes to fill in.

    Confidentiality & data protection: This research is confidential; your name will not be collected, and your personal information will never appear anywhere. Only my supervisors and I will have access to your data. The survey results will be stored in a secure location at the Erasmus University Rotterdam and will be kept ten years after the research ends to secure scientific integrity.

    Data sharing: The collected data will only be used by my supervisors and me for academic research purposes at Erasmus University Rotterdam. As a firm believer in the virtue of open-access science, the scientific article produced based on this survey’s outcome and the subsequent Ph.D. thesis will be fully available to the general public over the internet. Of course, no source data will be shared at this stage, only statistical results.

    Your individual rights: When you participate in the research, you have the right to request more information about the data collection, analysis or withdraw the consent and ask for data erasure before the dataset is locked and the manuscript submitted for publishing. You can exercise your rights under all applicable laws and regulations by submitting an email to [email protected].

    Best regards,

    Pascal Carpentier


    The views expressed in our blog are those of the author and not necessarily lowimpact.org's


    8 Comments

    • 1annbeirneanimalwhisperert January 31st, 2021

      What the heck is a Wiki is more invasion of privacy??????

    • 2Dave Darby January 31st, 2021

      annbeirneanimalwhisperert

      Here’s more info about wikis – https://www.lowimpact.org/lowimpact-topic/wikis/

      Why did you think it’s an invasion of privacy? It’s about the way we provide information on the website, via a network of specialists.

    • 3Pascal Capentier February 4th, 2021

      Hello,
      I would like to thank all the respondents for the survey. Your feedback is incredibly helpful!

      However, we need to reach at least 100 answers to have a meaningful statistic. This survey only takes 3 minutes to complete, and Lowimpact offers a chance to win a free online course to survey participants who completed the questionnaire. ?
      You be fantastic if you could participate :

      Here is the link – https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9sPWbZCjg69AOcl

      Of course, if you have questions, please feel free to contact me via email. I would be more than happy to answer your questions.

      Again thank you very much

      Pascal

    • 4Pascal February 4th, 2021

      Hello,
      I would like to thank all the respondents for the survey. Your feedback is incredibly helpful!

      However, we need to reach at least 100 answers to have a meaningful statistic. This survey only takes 3 minutes to complete, and Lowimpact offers a chance to win a free online course to survey participants who completed the questionnaire. ?

      It would be fantastic if you could participate :
      Here is the link – https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9sPWbZCjg69AOcl

      Of course, if you have questions, please feel free to contact me via email. I would be more than happy to answer your questions.

      Again, thank you very much
      Pascal

    • 5Olive Mary Smale March 1st, 2021

      such a fascinating area to study.

    • 6Joe Dee March 2nd, 2021

      To Dave Darby. Asking about possible invasions to ‘privacy’ is not an unreasonable question to ask as the increase of surveillance by ‘authority’ agencies are on the increase. The appeal of ‘low impact’ attracts those who like to enjoy some measure of privacy from the gaze of big bro.

    • 7Dave Darby March 2nd, 2021

      Joe Dee – completely agree about surveillance. One of the reasons we exist is to promote alternatives to corporate, data-harvesting entities. But a wiki is just a tool for adding information to the site. It’s for experts to debate about the topics they have expertise in. Visitors will have no access to it, and it will have no access for visitors.

    • 8Pascal March 5th, 2021

      Dear all,
      Thank you very much for answering the survey!
      Some of you raised questions regarding the survey structure and indeed, we realized that the last questions could be confusing.
      Our study intends to compare Lowimpact “reader” expectations and “contributor” expectations.
      We had somehow to find a common survey to address two very different groups of people.

      Our wording is sometimes confusing, and you may feel that this survey is for “contributors” only, I am sorry for that.
      I would be very interested in understanding if you share what you learn on the Lowimpact web site in real life (and not only in the comment section on the website).
      You may share what you learned on the website with friends and family, and in that case, you would be contributing to “knowledge sharing”.

      I certainly don’t want to bother anyone anymore. However, if, with this clarification in mind, you think you could take an extra minute or two to complete the survey that would be super insightful. (No worries, it will resume where you left off.)

      https://erasmusuniversity.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_9sPWbZCjg69AOcl

      Whether you wish to continue with the survey or not, thank you very much for helping us with this research.
      Of course, if you have questions, please feel free to contact me via email. I would be more than happy to answer your questions.
      Again, thank you very much
      Pascal

    Leave a comment

    We welcome questions

    Due to a spike in very clever spam, comments are moderated and take a little time to appear.

    There’s a crash coming – a slap from Mother Nature. This isn’t pessimistic; it’s realistic.

    The human impact on nature and on each other is accelerating and needs systemic change to reverse.

    We’re not advocating poverty, or a hair-shirt existence. We advocate changes that will mean better lives for almost everyone.

    Stay up to date

    Newsletter sign up is temporarily disabled

    Facebook icon Twitter icon

    All rights reserved © lowimpact 2022