“If your bank took bailout money, take your money out of that bank and put it in a credit union. Credit unions are owned by the people who have their money in the credit union.” – Michael Moore
What are credit unions?
Credit unions are co-operative financial institutions with local members (or members in the same trade). They provide savings accounts and low-interest loans, and members get dividends instead of interest. One of their prime purposes is to promote thrift and frugality, and members are generally encouraged to save rather than borrow. They are for everyone – including people on low incomes.
They represent a refreshing alternative to banks – banks that have in the 21st century cost millions of ordinary people an awful lot of money (and jobs), got bailed out by taxpayers, and continue to pay top executives enormous bonuses.
‘Local’ usually means within a local authority boundary, but credit unions can also be tied to a particular trade or profession, employer, trade union etc. This is called a ‘common bond’, which means that all members have something in common. Families of members can join too, even if they don’t share the common bond.
Loans are offered from members’ savings, and dividends are paid from interest received on loans. That’s it. There is no investment in risky schemes. Money is held in deposit with the Co-op Bank (ethical investment), or in government bonds.
The first credit unions were formed in Germany in the middle of the 19th century. The movement is now huge worldwide, with more than 200 million members in around 100 countries, and over US$1 trillion in assets. The World Council of Credit Unions exists to support and develop credit unions internationally.
What are the benefits of credit unions?
Their benefits are best appreciated by comparing credit unions to banks.
- they have never been responsible for international financial crashes, or been given billions of taxpayers’ (your) money
- they don’t get involved with ponzi-type schemes for making more money, so will never get caught up in the kind of sub-prime mess the banks did, because of greed
- their purpose is the financial health of their members – they are secure, sensible and promote thrift; thrift is of no interest whatsoever to banks, who have profits for shareholders and bonuses for executives to think about
- they have a democratic structure; decisions are made by a volunteer board (who are also members) – elected by all the members
- decisions are made on behalf of and for the benefit of the members (or they don’t get re-elected)
- banks have shareholders rather than members, and a paid board of directors; they make decisions based on what will make the biggest profits for their shareholders – customers don’t have a say
- credit unions are not-for-profit, but they can still make a surplus; but that surplus is used to cover expenses, and to benefit members via lower interest rates on loans, higher rates on savings, lower and fewer fees, free services etc.
- their aims are not just commercial (although they must be solvent and operate on a sound commercial footing); they are there to help their members save and borrow – especially people with very little money, who might be excluded from saving or borrowing with more conventional financial institutions
- their loans are cheap (see below)
- because they are embedded in local communities, members get involved with local events, small businesses, local charities etc.
- credit unions can be seen as part of a movement to transfer wealth and power from the rich and distribute it throughout society, which of course has implications for wider democracy
Great little advert for credit unions – from members of credit unions.
Who do you want your money to support – the shareholders and executives of banks, or local, democratic membership organisations?
What can I do?
You can join your local credit union, or start one if there isn’t a local one. Think about moving your savings account from your bank, and approaching your credit union for a loan if you need one, rather than your bank. The law recently changed to allow credit unions to offer current accounts. Ideally, why not see if your credit union has a current account, and use that too, and close your conventional bank account altogether?
Most credit unions allow you to join online, or you can fill in a form and start saving. You can find a list of UK credit unions at Find Your Credit Union.
If it’s a loan you’re looking for, you’d be better off approaching a credit union rather than a bank. If you borrow £1000 from a bank over 12 months, you’ll pay compound interest, so say for example the APR is 12%, you’ll pay 12% of the whole £1000, i.e. £120. With a credit union, you’ll pay interest each month on the amount left to pay, which means you’ll end up paying around £60 – making credit union loans around half the price of bank loans. Also, if you take out a loan and then lose your job, payments and interest are frozen until you find a new job. Because of the common bond, community involvement, the promotion of thrift and the low cost of loans, bad debt represents around 4% of loans, compared to 7% across the financial industry as a whole.
If you have a savings account, you won’t get interest, but you’ll get a dividend based on the profitability of the individual credit union – the interest paid on money lent, in other words. This is often more than bank interest, as credit union costs are low – lots of work is carried out by volunteer members. Savings are covered by the FSCS, and so there is no risk to members’ money if the credit union folds.
If there isn’t a credit union in your area, and you’d like to start one, ABCUL can provide training, information and advice, as can individual credit unions. It might be an idea to volunteer at a credit union first to get more of an idea of how they work.
At London Capital Credit Union, membership increased 60% in the year following the banking crisis. Credit unions are on the rise, for philosophical and very practical reasons. Why not get involved?
Thanks to Martin Groombridge of London Capital Credit Union for information.
Whilst you’re here, why not take a look at the other 20+ economy topics available? And don’t forget to visit our main topics page to explore over 200 aspects of low-impact living and our homepage to learn more about why we do what we do.
The views expressed here are those of the author and not necessarily lowimpact.org's
2 Comments on Credit unions
Jenni Stuart-Anderson - July 6th, 2021
Query: my daughter has a place on an MA course to study Sustainable Design but needs to raise funds to help cover it. “This masters course offers a unique opportunity to create a space to challenge the pre-existing paradigm, discover new technologies and environmentally motivated design thinkers. In combination with my 14 years of creative experience, I will explore how a variety of perspectives, traditions and technologies can contribute to innovative multidisciplinary outcomes in informing much needed changes in this field. I have met industry resistance towards placing sustainability at the heart of fashion practice, yet the entire life cycle of our clothing has climate consequences. With fashion as the second biggest polluting industry, we must embrace a diverse, analytical and visionary approach to meet the demands of a changing world.” Would a credit union be likely to help her with a low interest loan? Please advise.
Dave Darby - July 8th, 2021
Jenni – I’m talking with a potential advisor on credit unions at the moment, so they might be able to give more and better info; but as I understand it, someone receiving a loan would already be a member of a credit union, and to be a member, you would live in the locality that the credit union covers, or be a member of a profession that the credit union covers. Do you have a local credit union?